Feedback for moving threads and posts

[Catmandu]

Honestly I think we stay on topic pretty well compared to when this was an email only list.

LOL... that's because it was ONE LOOOOOOOONG thread!

[Lobot]

Honestly I think we stay on topic pretty well compared to when this was an email only list.

[Irishbearcat]

I agree with what you said, for the most part. I do think having 3 threads on Huggs is rediculous, but trying to stay on topic in a thread is boring.

[Catmandu]

If you want to critique the moderation being done, please post on the Feedback forum. If you have particular questions about particular threads and/or posts, include links to these in your feedback post.

FYI...
Do you know how many threads and posts I must go through each day to maintain some level of moderation consistency? I do the best I can with the spare time I have. I may miss a few here and there but I do get most of them.

I think the whole idea of "thread" is that a "thread" follows the thought process of the posters, it goes in the direction that the posters send it... not in the direction that one or two poeple direct it. Massage board threads are for conversations, I just don't understand why they need to be moved, if someone doesn't "like it" they don't have to read it right?

also, as you stated, it's difficult "equal" due to the multitude of posts to keep up with. I think you create more work for yourself by trying to dictate where threads should go.... Why not let the conversations go where they want, and like a simple economy "supply and demand: will determine the longevity/participation of said thread. Bad threads die, they shouldn't need to be "Managed"

You know, I am in the interenet business, and am on numerous message boards, and I KNOW BCN wants to be "unique" BUT, I have never been on a message board that handled things like things are handled here, not even close. I don't see threads getting moved all the time etc etc etc...

(I'm i in the right place for this comment?)

[jkwuc89]

If you want to critique the moderation being done, please post on the Feedback forum. If you have particular questions about particular threads and/or posts, include links to these in your feedback post.

FYI...
Do you know how many threads and posts I must go through each day to maintain some level of moderation consistency? I do the best I can with the spare time I have. I may miss a few here and there but I do get most of them.

I moved all of the Huggins vs. Cronin debate related posts to the "Debate Huggins" thread on the "Where are they now" forum. Let's try to keep this thread focused on the game.

If you want to talk about how the coaches may try to scheme against each other for this game, talk about that here.
If you want to debate who is the better coach, go to the "Debate Huggins" thread.

Respectfully, I disagree. You left several Ralph1950 posts on that subject right here in this thread. Like referees, I'd hope for consistency across the board.

[Catmandu]

I moved all of the Huggins vs. Cronin debate related posts to the "Debate Huggins" thread on the "Where are they now" forum. Let's try to keep this thread focused on the game.

Keith, can't we for the one week we play him allow a thread to stay a thread? All of the Cronin vs huggins debate is approriate THIS Week (at least till Wednesday after the game.