Transfer portal

[RedDog]

2 star coming out of high school plus injury last year. not sure how that equates to an impact player at our level (other than Colerain ties of course) but I hope you are right. He made an official visit to Iowa but thats all i have seen, Anything new?

[Bearcat Chris]

Miami U OL Rusty Feth (Colerain) in the portal and both Justin Williams and Bearcat Journal are saying to "keep an eye on" this one. So sounds like he's announcing for UC pretty soon. 4-year starter and 2nd team all-MAC.

Absolutely pick up Rusty Feth. Another Colerain stud. Huge. Had a bad senior year because of torn ACL. Would be an immediate impact player.

B.C.

[Carin's Dad]

Couldn't agree more. I'm almost to the point that I wouldn't mind seeing another major split with the top 30 or so schools going and doing their own semi-pro type of system and let college football get back more to what it used to be. I agree that there needs to be stipends and also some form of pay for NIL. But when recruits are committing based on 13 million dollar NIL deals and then backing out when it falls through, that's insanity. The worst part is that so many of these kids will be influenced poorly and think they've arrived with a much smaller NIL deal and then fall through the cracks because they lose themselves. Hopefully someone or something gets this under control. It's become the wild west right now.

One way to police the NIL mess is for schools to set up their NIL combines, but officials are afraid of appearing to "pay" their athletes. College athletics are headed for something. Something probably better for bigger budgets, as usual.

[Bearcatdave72]

We are in agreement and we have only been marginally successful in picking up portal guys although I must say we have at least picked up equal or better value to what we have lost. Eason was really the only major hit.
Can't wait for the covid year to go away. Have no idea who will even be on our team next year.
Water over the dam and its next to impossible to take entitlements back, but there must be portal limits and rules put in place and definitely some financial limits on NIL deals. Pay for play is just wrong. This started as the players are entitled to be compensated for their images and receive some stipend to support their needs and help their families, and has exploded into a full scale bidding war with no limits. They are not employees of the universities but are the beneficiaries of hundreds of thousands of dollars of education that must me factored in.

Couldn't agree more. I'm almost to the point that I wouldn't mind seeing another major split with the top 30 or so schools going and doing their own semi-pro type of system and let college football get back more to what it used to be. I agree that there needs to be stipends and also some form of pay for NIL. But when recruits are committing based on 13 million dollar NIL deals and then backing out when it falls through, that's insanity. The worst part is that so many of these kids will be influenced poorly and think they've arrived with a much smaller NIL deal and then fall through the cracks because they lose themselves. Hopefully someone or something gets this under control. It's become the wild west right now.

[RedDog]

We are in agreement and we have only been marginally successful in picking up portal guys although I must say we have at least picked up equal or better value to what we have lost. Eason was really the only major hit.
Can't wait for the covid year to go away. Have no idea who will even be on our team next year.
Water over the dam and its next to impossible to take entitlements back, but there must be portal limits and rules put in place and definitely some financial limits on NIL deals. Pay for play is just wrong. This started as the players are entitled to be compensated for their images and receive some stipend to support their needs and help their families, and has exploded into a full scale bidding war with no limits. They are not employees of the universities but are the beneficiaries of hundreds of thousands of dollars of education that must me factored in.

[Oldtimer_UC_fan]

No, Red and Black is exactly right. Transfers don't impact HS player scholly availability but the extra years for covid and graduates certainly does. If guys stay another year or two, there are that many scholarships not available for HS kids. The scholarship limit didn't change but if the guys who have them dont give them up then they cant be reassigned. We should be about thru that but when this crap started, about 1500 new kids didnt get schollys that otherwise would have.

I was only referring to the portal. Yes, the Covid extra year does.

[London 'Cat]

The players who are seniors, either true or redshirt, this season should be the last class that this will affect. Those players are eligible for an en extra year. But, as I understand the rule it is the university’s option to ask for that extra year.

[RedDog]

No, Red and Black is exactly right. Transfers don't impact HS player scholly availability but the extra years for covid and graduates certainly does. If guys stay another year or two, there are that many scholarships not available for HS kids. The scholarship limit didn't change but if the guys who have them dont give them up then they cant be reassigned. We should be about thru that but when this crap started, about 1500 new kids didnt get schollys that otherwise would have.

[Oldtimer_UC_fan]

Yeah, I get it and hope many will still sign with another school. I also think it will get better after the last class allowed to use the COVID exemption graduates. Right now, there are more players available at every level and the scholarship limits didn't change. This limits the number of high school players who will get an offer and the number of transfers who will find a landing spot. Now, if we can just put better rules on NIL to allow players to maximize worth while penalizing/stopping pay-4-play

Not sure it limits high school players. Opening at one school and a used scholarship at another.

[red_n_black_attack]

True, but it's their own choice.

Yeah, I get it and hope many will still sign with another school. I also think it will get better after the last class allowed to use the COVID exemption graduates. Right now, there are more players available at every level and the scholarship limits didn't change. This limits the number of high school players who will get an offer and the number of transfers who will find a landing spot. Now, if we can just put better rules on NIL to allow players to maximize worth while penalizing/stopping pay-4-play

[Oldtimer_UC_fan]

The Athletic reported around 1000 players signed, with nearly 1500 in the portal. Either way, that is a lot of kids possibly no longer having a scholarship to continue their education.

True, but it's their own choice.

[red_n_black_attack]

On3 is stating that 1325 players went into the portal during the past portal window.

The Athletic reported around 1000 players signed, with nearly 1500 in the portal. Either way, that is a lot of kids possibly no longer having a scholarship to continue their education.

[GoBearcats31]

Miami U OL Rusty Feth (Colerain) in the portal and both Justin Williams and Bearcat Journal are saying to "keep an eye on" this one. So sounds like he's announcing for UC pretty soon. 4-year starter and 2nd team all-MAC.

[Lobot]

On3 is stating that 1325 players went into the portal during the past portal window.

[Lobot]

Texas State? Aren't they the powerhouse that produces NFL players annually? Was Texas State the university that Scott Bakula starred in the football movie "Necessary Roughness"?

The name is the same.TSU had a different name when the movie came out. Texas State just moved up to FBS a couple of years ago I think and it's not a good program all. Even Rice has a better football history. A couple of years ago the coach (Spavital?) did something crazy and didn't recruit any HS students. He pulled all his players from the existing roster and the portal. He got fired in this past offseason.

I think this was a move to get closer to home for Drew since he's from the Dallas area and it's probably not his final stop. He's better than TSU.